La Tela di Carlotta
it en es

Christmas and Montessori, are they incompatible?

Dec 13, 2016

Even before being parents and starting our Montessori journey, Alex and I often discussed about Christmas and how to handle it with our kids. We’re not religious, we usually work over the Christmas period, and we see it more like a consumeristic festivity than anything else. Don’t take me wrong, I personally love giving (and receiving) gifts, especially if I have something “just perfect” in mind, but I don’t feel the need to wait till Christmas in order to do it.

On top of that, after embarking on our Montessori journey, I started feeling like Christmas the way I know it (the tree, Santa Claus, the gifts) is not compatible with the kind of lifestyle we’d like for our kids. The whole Montessori philosophy is based on always telling the truth to our kids and deeply respecting them, which culminates in the Montessori motto ”Follow the child”.

So isn’t introducing fantasy characters like Santa Claus, the Three Wise Men, the Tooth Fairy, the Easter Bunny… a way of lying to our kids?

We’ve been thinking a lot about this in the past few years, and today I’d like to share a few of our reflections with you (thanks also to Montessori en Casa and her Reto Montessori webinars for always being such an amazing source of inspiration and self questioning for me).

Make what you want of your life and your traditions

First of all, you might feel judged by something I write in this post. Please, please, please, DON’T. I’m not judging you. In fact, I strongly believe that traditions (and life) are what you want to (or like to) make of them.

Parents should decide freely what to do with their little ones at home: if you are raising you child Montessori, but you want your Christmas filled with red Santa costumes and gifts under the tree, go ahead and do it (I had it in my childhood and loved it!), but make it a conscious decision, reflect on what it means for you and your family, don’t do it just because “that’s how you do Christmas”, think of possible consequences, of the meaning it’ll have for your kids, in what ways this decision might clash with the lifestyle you want to lead and, if so, how to handle it.

In this post, I’ll tell you what we decided to do as parents in our household, but again, please don’t let our personal decisions make you feel judged or criticised.

We don't want to lie to our kids

Alex and I came to the conclusion that if we introduced Santa Claus in Oliver’s life as a real person who flies on a sleigh, comes down the chimney at night and brings presents—trying to hide the truth for as long as possible in order to keep the magic alive—we would be lying to him. We simply don’t want that, so we won’t do it. Simple, right? :-)

The journey we embarked on through the gorgeous Montessori philosophy just happened to match exactly what we already felt—that lying to our kids about anything at all, in the long term undermines their trust in us and their feeling respected as individuals.

Let me give you a silly example: we’re driving, Oliver starts crying and I tell him “We’re almost home” when I perfectly know we’re still very far away. This is just one example of the many “white lies” that we tell our kids daily.

But in the long term, what kind of message do these lies send to my kids? That they can’t trust me and my words anymore. Telling him that Santa Claus exists and is real will eventually backfire when he finally learns the truth and that we, his parents who he trusts, contributed to the lie.

BUT.

We want to respect our kids' right to believe

What if Oliver one day comes home from nursery telling us excitedly all about Santa? Because it WILL happen! Will we tell him he’s wrong, that it’s all a big, fat lie? No, we won’t. We’ll listen to all the stories he has to tell us, and wait for him to ask questions.

When he does (because he will!)—mom, does Santa really exist and come on a sleigh down the chimney to bring me gifts?—we won’t lie to him. We’ll tell him that he doesn’t exist, but that it’s a beautiful story full of magic and that he is free to believe it’s real—and it might even be fun!

We will ask questions, and encourage him to find his own answers (can a man really fit down the chimney? How can he go back up again? Can a sleigh really fly? Kids find creative answers when they want to believe!) and to feel free to disagree with anybody (including us) if he thinks they’re wrong.

No need to give up Christmas traditions

We don’t believe in Santa, we’re not religious, we don’t follow the typical traditions… does it mean that Christmas is off limits for us? Not at all. Christmas is full of beautiful, interesting traditions that are different in each and every culture, and I can’t wait to explore them all with our kids, and learn all the different ways to celebrate it in other Countries.

As for us, we won’t have a nativity scene because we don’t embrace the religious aspect of it, but we will talk about nativity scenes, we might have a Christmas tree and learn about its origin—did you know that this tradition, like the actual date we celebrate Christmas, have pagan origins that go back way before they were related to Christianity? In the same way, we’ll buy books and learn about the origin of the Nativity Scene, Santa Claus, the Three Wise Men, their meaning in our culture and other cultures…

There’s so much more to Christmas than holiday from school, gifts and fantasy characters—and that’s what I’d like to get my kids excited about!

What about gifts?

This is a tricky one. Alex and I have stopped giving each other gifts on Christmas day, because we want to give gifts when we find something we love or when we simply feel like it. This way, we also feel free from the consumeristic aspect of Christmas, from the run to the perfect present, the waste of money on a gift at all costs.

In this regard, I’d like to quote Cristina from Montessori en Casa who wrote in her thoughtful blog post:

It is no news that we live in a consumer society, but on the dates close to Christmas the consumeristic fever is fired and it seems like if we don't buy everything that we see we can't be happy. I have often been horrified when in some film or TV shows (including children's ones) I hear sentences like:"Oh no, all the presents have disappeared, we have to find them to save Christmas!"W-H-A-T? Are you telling me that we need gifts to "save" Christmas? If there are no gifts, Christmas is not worth celebrating anymore? What kind of message is that?The bad news is that we are so accustomed to this kind of messages that sometimes we are not even aware of all the brainwashing messages we receive around these dates—even worse when it comes to our children, who are building their scale of values and receive those messages as valid and positive.

BUT.

I always loved finding presents under the Christmas tree on Christmas morning, so I might try and find a way to keep that tradition alive for our kids. In this blog post you’ll find a nice idea I’ve been reading in many blogs—which we might adopt in the future.

Respecting other people's way of Christmas

One thing that we realised, though, is that we can’t force our way of Christmas on others. Christmas is a great time to get together with family (especially when you live far away) for one simple reason: people have holidays from work!

My mother will be here for Christmas this year, she’s very religious, Christmas has a different meaning to her than it does to us, and although we won’t join her for the midnight mass or in celebrating the birth of Jesus, we want to respect her way of Christmas, and we want Oliver to learn about it, too, when he’s old enough to make up in his own mind.

And as long as other we all respect each other’s way of Christmas—we accept if they want to give gifts or have a special meal, and they respect that we don’t go to mass or pretend that Santa is real—I’m sure we can all enjoy our different ways of Christmas.

Don't feel judged, our way is no better than yours!

I feel like I have to repeat myself here, as I find this a delicate subject for many people, especially when it crosses their religious belief: we decided to celebrate Christmas this way—finding our own special things, not giving into the consumeristic aspect of it, making it an occasion to learn about different cultures in the world, and sharing it with family in a respectful way—and we feel like it works well with our Montessori lifestyle. But you don’t have to do the same.

I always say it, extremes are not healthy: there’s black, there’s white, and all the shades of grey in between. Enjoy exploring all of them and finding your own way of Christmas.

Merry Christmas, everybody!


I told you a little bit about our Christmas traditions, and now I’m curious to hear about yours. Whether you’re religious or not, Montessori or not, how do you celebrate Christmas with your kids? And how did you celebrate it before kids or when you were kids yourself?

Tell me what you think

Did you like it? Do you agree or disagree? I'd love to hear from you.

I think you'll like these

The blog

I write mainly about Montessori, parenthood, and multilingualism. Here are some recent posts.

Montessori
One day a few years ago my husband came home and said, "Why don't we put a mattress on the floor in the baby room? It'd be much more natural". "Never" was my reply. That's how our Montessori journey started. Since then we've been living, breathing and applying the philosophy at home day in and day out, starting from ourselves. Because educating children starts from the parents.
Bean and seed mosaic
I'm not perfect. I'm aware
DIY yoga cards for kids
Children at the restaurant: let's recalibrate expectations
Don't ask your children to share their toys
Those "good job" that erode our children's confidence
Our Montessori birthday
Two alternatives to screens that my kids love
Using fear and threats to control children is never right!
"Stop crying!" doesn't work
Living sustainably
Living sustainably for me doesn’t only mean to have a more eco-friendly lifestyle. It means to make decisions that are sustainable for our planet, the people on it, but also for our life, our lifestyle, and our happiness. It means to take any daily chance to evolve and be happier, healthier, kinder, more responsible and more caring human beings—the only sustainable way for a meaningful future.
Face yoga is an act of self love
Why you should wear the same outfit twice on Instagram
The power of creating habits (and why you should do it, even if you then break them!)
Responsible eating is the diet of the future (Would you like to teach it to your kids?)
The power of NOT complaining: can you do it for a whole month?
Clean up your planet, please!
Infographic: 8 steps to switch to cloth nappies (a guide for reluctant parents)
A personal note on happiness
A personal note on social media
A change of life always widens your horizons
New to La Tela?
I’ve prepared collections on various topics that I’ve written over the years. Perhaps you’ll find one that interests you.

Travel

We sold everything to travel the world for two years. We're currently in New Zealand.

Books

In 2020 I wrote 4 books for the Italian collection “Gioca and Impara con il metodo Montessori” curated by Grazia Honegger Fresco. The collection is a project by Il Corriere della Sera and La Gazzetta dello Sport.

We also implemented the workshops of the last 15 volumes of the collection with Oliver and Emily.

Podcast

On my podcast, “Educare con calma”, I talk about various topics, from Montessori to sustainability. Only in Italian!

Oct 16, 2020 • 19m
La nostra routine con i bimbi
Mi chiedete spessissimo quale sia la nostra routine a casa con i bimbi e in questo episodio vi svelo che noi, una routine vera e propria, non ce l'abbiamo. Abbiamo una routine minima e indispensabile, che è un concetto che mi sono totalmente inventata su due piedi mentre parlavo a briglia sciolta in questo episodio, ma che credo funzioni davvero. Almeno per noi. La routine minima e indispensabile, secondo me, risponde anche a un altro "problema": trovo che ci bombardino spesso con l'idea del...
11
Oct 9, 2020 • 24m
Sostenibilità: come sensibilizzare i bambini e i giovani adulti | Con Cristiana Cerri Gambarelli
In questa puntata a due voci di Educare con Calma – divisa a metà perché amo gli episodi corti - parliamo di sostenibilità e per farlo ho invitato mia sorella, Cristiana Cerri Gambarelli, project manager della Federazione dei Giovani Verdi Europei e un esempio per chiunque voglia intraprendere un viaggio nella sostenibilità: negli ultimi ha cambiato tutta la sua vita per ridurre la sua impronta di carbonio e per prendere ogni giorno decisioni più sostenibili per il nostro pianeta e in questa ...
10
Oct 2, 2020 • 24m
Intraprendere un viaggio nella sostenibilità | Con Cristiana Cerri Gambarelli
In questa puntata a due voci di Educare con Calma – divisa a metà perché amo gli episodi corti - parliamo di sostenibilità e per farlo ho invitato mia sorella, Cristiana Cerri Gambarelli, project manager della Federazione dei Giovani Verdi Europei e un esempio per chiunque voglia intraprendere un viaggio nella sostenibilità: negli ultimi ha cambiato tutta la sua vita per ridurre la sua impronta di carbonio e per prendere ogni giorno decisioni più sostenibili per il nostro pianeta e in questa ...
9

Instagram

I update Instagram almost every day to be "close" to my family far away.

Why La Tela di Carlotta?
I dreamed of the name La Tela di Carlotta. One morning I woke up and in my dreams I had created a blog named just like the American novel (Charlotte's Web). Many years and endless ups and downs later, this web of thoughts and stories is my work. It took me a long time to understand what kind of online presence I wanted and today I know: I'm transparent, I show real life, I don't advertise, I only recommend sustainable brands (and not only because they pay me) and I believe in the value of my blog and my courses—because if we don't believe in the value of our work, no one will believe in it for us.
Carlotta
Carlotta dreaming of La Tela
I know! I don't want it to be over yet either.